A review of Athearn’s F45/FP45Series Genesis engines
A comparison versus brass
|
|---|
Overland Brass FP 45 |
|---|
Background:
|
First Impressions:
I was very surprised when I opened the new Athearn FP45/F45 boxes. Gone are the plastic molded cartons that hold the engine in place. Instead the engines are mounted on a piece of wood and held by two screws. This allows the engine to float in the center of the box preventing any damage to the engine. The challenge was finding the right screwdriver and not stripping the head of the screw. Once I off the piece of wood the tank needed to be screwed on the bottom. In the process one of the tank fillers broke off and had to glue the piece. Overall I like this new concept, just have to remember to bring the right screwdriver and not strip the screw holes.
|
New Athearn
Brass Overland |
Brass Overland |
|---|
Athearn |
|---|
Model details:
The challenge for Athearn has been creating models that are as good and accurate as brass. For this review I pulled out my Overland Brass Models to compare to the Athearn in a side-by-side comparison, the results were very interesting. The brass Overland was manufactured in 1997 for comparison. The FP45 Warbonnet placements of the letters on the body referring to old pictures were more accurate for the Athearn and off for the Overland. The F45 there were more differences in the markings. The yellow strip on the door is missing on the brass piece but Athearn got it right on. Second the trucks on the Overland were silver, which is incorrect. The model pictured had to be painted black. |
Overland Brass |
|---|
Athearn |
|---|
Performance:
Very smooth running engine and the momentum has been added into the engine. Great performance |
Sound System
Athearn still uses the MRC decoder, which sounds ok, sometimes more like a jet engine. I had to turn down the diesel sound to a setting of 1. The horn did not sound right and changed CV 50 to 13. |
Overall
Highly recommend! I'm buying more from the next series. |
New Athearn FP45







